If you’re trying to lose weight, there’s a good chance you’ve come across both Weight Watchers and MyFitnessPal. They’re two of the most popular weight loss apps available today, but they take very different approaches.
WeightWatchers focuses on simplifying food choices through its Points system and behavior-based coaching, while MyFitnessPal centers on calorie counting, nutrition tracking, and detailed food data.
So which one is right for you? The answer depends largely on your personality, goals, and how you prefer to track your progress. In this guide, we’ll compare WeightWatchers and MyFitnessPal side by side, including how they work, what they cost, and how newer options, like prescription GLP-1 weight loss medications, fit into the picture.
The Core Difference: Points vs. Calories
At its heart, the WeightWatchers vs. MyFitnessPal debate comes down to simplicity versus precision. I’ll explain:
WeightWatchers: A Simpler, Behavior-Focused Approach
10 Months: 60% Off
1. Core plan only $10 per month! Shortest commitment for...Show More
1. Core plan only $10 per month! Shortest commitment for the amazing $10 rate! If you want a shorter commitment it will cost more per month. Click to apply coupon and view details of this offer at WeightWatchers.com: Show Less
WeightWatchers is designed to make healthy eating feel less like math homework. Instead of tracking calories and nutrients individually, foods are assigned a Points value based on factors such as calories, protein, fiber, sugar, and saturated fat. Foods that are generally more filling and nutritious tend to have lower Point values, while foods higher in sugar and saturated fat tend to have higher values.
The program also includes a large list of ZeroPoint foods, such as many fruits, vegetables, eggs, fish, and lean proteins. These foods don’t count against your daily Points budget, which can make the program feel more flexible and sustainable for many people. Beyond food tracking, WeightWatchers places a strong emphasis on behavior change, (like Noom) habit building, and community support.
Tip: WW offers very good promotions for new and returning customers that save about 50% off the cost, plus discounts for groups like students and teachers!
MyFitnessPal: Detailed Nutrition Tracking
MyFitnessPal takes a more data-driven approach. Rather than converting food into Points, it tracks calories, macronutrients, and other nutrition information directly. The platform features one of the largest food databases available, making it easy to log meals, scan barcodes, and monitor daily intake.
For people who enjoy numbers, DIY, and want complete control over their nutrition, MyFitnessPal can be incredibly powerful. Whether you’re tracking calories, protein, carbohydrates, fat, or specific fitness goals, the app provides detailed information without steering you toward particular food choices. It simply gives you the data and lets you decide how to use it.
Weight Watchers vs MyFitnessPal Comparison:
Feature
Weight Watchers
MyFitnessPal
Free Version?
No
Yes (food and calorie logging with ads)
Monthly Cost
$10–12/mo with promotion
$19.99/mo
Medical / GLP-1 Plan
Yes
No
Summary
Point system, ZeroPoint foods, behavioral lessons
Calorie budgets, macro targets, database scanning
I think it’s surprising that WW costs less than MyFitnessPal, but if you commit to a year, they both cost about the same.
Ratings Comparison:
As you can see, both WeightWatchers and MyFitnessPal are rated very highly on the App Store based on millions of ratings:
While the difference between those ratings is negligible, there’s one important difference: WeightWatchers offers the option of GLP-1 weight loss medications with their MED+ plan.
WeightWatchers Clinic vs. MyFitnessPal for GLP-1 Users
One of the biggest differences between WeightWatchers and MyFitnessPal is how they fit into the growing world of medical weight loss. WeightWatchers Med+ combines access to healthcare providers with nutrition and lifestyle support, creating a more comprehensive experience for people using GLP-1 medications such as Wegovy or Zepbound.
Because these medications can significantly reduce appetite, WeightWatchers adapts the experience to focus on important habits like eating enough protein, staying hydrated, and getting adequate nutrition. The program also includes behavioral coaching designed to help members build sustainable routines that can support long-term success, whether they remain on medication or eventually stop taking it.
MyFitnessPal remains a powerful nutrition-tracking tool, but it does not offer GLP-1 medication or medical support. You can certainly use MyFitnessPal while taking a GLP-1 medication prescribed by your doctor, but you’ll be responsible for managing your healthcare and nutrition plan independently.
Which Is Better: WeightWatchers or MyFitnessPal?
The truth is that neither app is universally better. The right choice depends on your personality, goals, and how you prefer to approach weight loss.
WeightWatchers is better if…
You want support beyond food tracking. WeightWatchers combines nutrition guidance, behavior-change tools, community support, and, for some members, access to medical weight loss services through WeightWatchers Clinic.
You feel overwhelmed by calorie counting. If tracking every calorie leaves you frustrated or burned out, the Points system can feel much simpler and easier to stick with long-term. The inclusion of ZeroPoint foods also provides a level of flexibility that many people find refreshing.
You benefit from structure and accountability. WeightWatchers is designed to help people gradually build healthier habits rather than simply monitor numbers. If encouragement, coaching, and community support help keep you motivated, WW has a lot to offer.
MyFitnessPal May Be Better If…
You enjoy tracking detailed nutrition data. If you’re the type of person who likes seeing exactly how many calories, grams of protein, carbohydrates, fiber, or sodium you’re consuming, MyFitnessPal provides an impressive level of detail and customization.
Fitness and performance are major goals. For people focused on strength training, muscle building, endurance sports, or macro tracking, MyFitnessPal’s data-driven approach can make meal planning and recovery easier to manage.
You prefer a do-it-yourself approach. If you’re already working with your own healthcare provider, or simply don’t need coaching or community support, MyFitnessPal gives you the tools to track your progress without adding extra layers of guidance.
You’re looking for a strong free option. MyFitnessPal’s free version remains one of the most capable nutrition-tracking tools available, making it an attractive choice for budget-conscious users.
The Bottom Line
Both WeightWatchers and MyFitnessPal can be effective tools for weight loss, but they solve different problems.
WeightWatchers focuses on building healthier habits through a structured Points system, coaching, and support. MyFitnessPal focuses on giving you detailed nutrition data and the flexibility to manage your own plan.
If you’d rather spend less time thinking about calories and more time building sustainable habits, WeightWatchers may be the better choice. If you enjoy tracking numbers, setting custom nutrition goals, and having complete control over your data, MyFitnessPal may be a better fit. The best program is the one you’ll actually use consistently, and the one that makes healthy choices feel easier, not harder.
Have you tried WeightWatchers and MyFitnessPal? If you have an opinion, drop us a line below. Thanks for visiting PrettySweet!
WeightWatchers is generally rated very highly and has long been a popular choice for those seeking a highly-rated structured weight loss program. However, recent feedback from users on platforms like Reddit, the Better Business Bureau(BBB), and ConsumerAffairs highlights several concerns that potential members should be aware of before signing up.
Here are the top five complaints about Weight Watchers based on real user experiences:
1. Challenging Cancellation Process & Unexpected Charges
Many users report difficulties when trying to cancel their WW memberships. Despite following the provided procedures, some continue to be charged, leading to frustration and billing complaints.
“I canceled my subscription and deactivated my account 2 months ago, but WW has charged my card 3 times since then.” — Reddit user reddit.com
Additionally, some members feel misled by promotional offers that later result in long-term commitments.
“I signed up for WW under the impression of a discount. After trying for 6 months, I have not lost any weight… I attempted to cancel and was told I would continue to be charged until December.” — BBB Complaint bbb.org
2. Inadequate Customer Support
Users frequently express dissatisfaction with WW’s customer service, citing long wait times and unhelpful responses.
“I have called customer service and waited on hold for half an hour with no answer, sent an email to an address that is apparently no longer monitored.” — Reddit user reddit.com
Such experiences can be particularly distressing when dealing with billing issues or seeking assistance with the program.
3. Concerns with the WW Clinic & Sequence Program
WW’s foray into medical weight loss through its Clinic and Sequence programs has garnered criticism. Some users report being prescribed medications without adequate medical oversight, leading to adverse effects. (source: reddit.com)
“Their Sequence program turned out to be terrible!! It is medically UNETHICAL. A real nightmare.” — Reddit user reddit.com
Others feel the program lacks transparency and fails to deliver on its promises.
“I have been paying $99 a month for absolutely nothing! I was denied insurance coverage for numerous semaglutides.” — Reddit user reddit.com
4. WW Program Changes Leading to Confusion
“If it ain’t broke then don’t try to fix it,” right?
WW has undergone several program changes over the years including the point system, which some long-time users find confusing or less effective.
“I am not a huge fan of The Plan. I feel that they really ding healthy fats way too much and demonize sugar.” — Reddit user reddit.com
Such unnecessary changes can make it challenging for members to maintain consistency and trust in the program’s efficacy.
5. WW Perceived Value vs. Cost
Some users question whether WW offers sufficient value for its cost, especially when compared to free or less expensive alternatives.
“I found Noom to be a complete waste of time and money and would strongly urge users to consider different platforms.” — Reddit user
While this comment references a different program, it reflects a broader sentiment among users evaluating the cost-effectiveness of weight loss solutions.
Final Thoughts
Now, you’ll need to take these complaints and bad reviews with a grain of salt. Why? Tens of thousands of women and men love the WW program and it’s consistently rated as the best commercial weight loss program by U.S. News.
While WW has helped many individuals on their weight loss journeys, it’s essential to consider these common complaints when deciding if it’s the right fit for you. As with any program, individual experiences may vary, and it’s crucial to research and choose a solution that aligns with your personal needs and preferences.
WW (Weight Watchers) Before and after pics: If you are thinking of joining a wellness or weight loss program like Weight Watchers, it can be very inspiring to see before and after photos showing users’ weight loss transformations. These photos are scattered online and often posted on WeightWatchers.com and Instagram.
Well, the good news is you don’t have to spend hours scrolling and clicking to find pictures, as we did the hard work for you! Here are our favorite before and after pics of women and men with their WeightWatchers weight loss results.
Thinking of joining? Check out their featured sign-up promo below to save up to 50% on the cost, or see all coupons here.
*People following the WW program can expect to lose 1-2 lbs per week.
Emily’s WW Transformation, Wow!
“But it wasn’t the number on the scale or the size of my pants that changed me, It was the consistency and strength it took to show up day after day for myself that made me who I am today. I couldn’t cut corners, lie, or fake my way to change, I actually had to put in the work and make good choices even when no one was holding me accountable.” -emily_myfitnessgal
Maddie Lost 90 lbs With Weight Watchers!
5 Things That Helped Me Succeed
1. Tracking all of my meals in the WW app—and doing it honestly! 2. Drinking more water. 3. Relying on ZeroPoint foods. 4. Using my weekly Points®. I learned that they’re there for a reason and that I could still indulge in the foods I love. 5. Understanding that WeightWatchers is a lifestyle, not a diet.
“My advice for new members: do this for you and don’t quit! You can accomplish anything you set your mind to.” – Maddie R.
Naomi: Before & After Weight Watchers:
“Being healthy isn’t just about lifting weights, it’s about feeling comfortable in your skin and getting out and seeing the world with your family. I want my kids to know it’s worth it to take care of themselves.” – Naomi M.
Adam: Before & After 70 lb Weight Loss:
“My biggest non-scale victory has been playing sports again. I’ve gotten into a basketball league. Now I’m trying to get into softball. Being able to do things that I couldn’t do before is huge.
How I feel about myself has changed so much, too. I would get down on myself all the time before. I like who I see in the mirror today. I like how I look.” – Adam Y.
Jacqueline Before & After 3 Months:
“I used food as a coping mechanism after losing my grandfather. My eating habits, my negative relationship with food, had a lot to do with my mental health. The mind-body connection is a real thing and so I knew that I wanted to try a more holistic way to lose weight. That’s where joining WW came into play…”
Lauren’s WW Transformation:
Back in 2019, I was 27, pre-diabetic, and had high cholesterol and high blood pressure. I work as a middle school student mentor, and I was finding it hard to keep up with my students. I knew I needed a change, and it was my doctor who pointed me to WW. One of the biggest changes I’ve experienced in my WW journey is a new energy for life. I’m able to keep up with those around me—including my students! In fact, they now have to keep up with me!
Stephanie Lost 111 Lbs. w/ WW!
“Before joining WW, I never ever ran before. I thought I couldn’t run and never would be able to, so I’d participate in 5K races as a walker. During lockdown last year, I decided I wanted to learn how to run and basically coached myself on how to do it. This past weekend, I RAN my first 4-mile race! It was awesome and I’m SO glad I went and did it. If it weren’t for WW, I would’ve never had the confidence to do any of this.”
Brittany Lost 45+ Pounds! WeightWatchers Before & After Pics:
MEMBER SINCE: 2015
JOINED WW TO: Reduce her blood pressure and gain the energy she needed to play with her kids
USED TO: Eat king-sized candy bars and two or more cans of soda every day
NOW SHE: Replaces soda with water and her daily candy bar with a banana and chocolate peanut butter powder to satisfy her sweet tooth!
WW WEIGHT LOSS RESULTS: 45.2lbs
Letisha Lost 40 Pounds w/ WW!
“My husband was the only one who truly knew how depressed and uncomfortable I was in my own skin when I joined WW after Oprah’s 2020 Vision Tour. During the pandemic, I began to cook more and pay attention to exactly what I was putting in my body. I didn’t feel like I was on a diet—it was a new way of life. More recently, I’ve started lifting weights, and I’ve lost 40lbs and 4 sizes!”
– From WW Instagram post
WW: Sara & Patrick Lost 30+ Pounds Each
If you have a minute, here’s an inspiring success story of a couple that does WW (Weight Watchers) together:
WW Before & After: Macy
WEIGHT WATCHERS member since Oct. 2018
JOINED WW to: Get more comfortable in her own skin
USED TO: Seek comfort in food and see exercise as a punishment
NOW SHE: Eats lighter versions of the foods she loves and embraces activities like yoga and hot pilates because they make her feel amazing!
LOST: 56.4lbs ?
Before & After Pictures: Gladys
MEMBER SINCE: 2018
JOINED WW TO: Lose the weight she gained after a devastating loss
USED TO: Go to the drive-thru or snack all day long instead of eating substantial meals, then binge eat at night
NOW SHE: Uses measuring cups to monitor her portions, goes to Workshops for accountability, packs a lunch for work, and swaps processed snacks for fruits and veggies
WW WEIGHT LOSS RESULTS: 40lbs ?
Before & After: Chris Lost 100+ Pounds!
MEMBER SINCE: 2016
JOINED WW TO: Support his aunt, a breast cancer survivor, at WW Workshops
USED TO: Overeat chips, chocolate, and ice cream; avoid activity because it seemed too difficult; and hate how he looked in photos
NOW HE: Measures food servings and tracks what he eats; dances for exercise; and loves the way he looks in photos
LOST: 123 pounds
Eric Lost 75 Pounds With Weight Watchers After 3 Months
MEMBER SINCE: 2018
JOINED WW TO: Keep up with his kids and achieve wellness
USED TO: Eat fried foods all day—and night—at work in addition to regular meals
NOW HE: Pays more attention to why and when he eats, drinks more water, and meal preps to get ahead of the day
JOINED WW TO: Alleviate back pain and feel more confident at the gym
USED TO: Eat fast food every night and crash diet
NOW SHE: Cooks WeightWatchers-friendly versions of her favorite foods and works out regularly at the gym
WEIGHT LOSS: 119 pounds! ?
Already on WW? We have a free points calculator here
Georgia Lost 121 Pounds!
WW MEMBER SINCE: November 2017
JOINED WW TO: Alleviate arthritis pain ahead of her 40th birthday and feel more comfortable and beautiful
USED TO: Look for quick-fix diets; eat lots of fast food; cook big plates of pasta or heavy fried meals at home, and eat her kids’ snacks and leftovers
NOW SHE: Eats more lean meats and veggies, tracks less nutritious foods, visits fast-food restaurants less frequently, and strength trains, spins, or runs almost every day
WEIGHT LOSS:121.5lbs* ?
*Georgia lost weight on a prior WW program and is continuing with the WW PersonalPoints Program™. People following the WW program can expect to lose 1-2 pounds/week
*Related: Weight Watchers Zero Point Foods List
Hannah Lost 36 Pounds With WW!
“Despite constant crash dieting, I was miserable when I looked in the mirror before I downloaded the WW app and finally changed my relationship with food. WW helped me learn about portion size and how to be more mindful throughout the day after eating something higher in SmartPoints. Now that I’ve changed physically and mentally, I feel so much more confident. I’m so thankful for this program that has turned my life around!” – Hannah
Before & After: Tamara
WW MEMBER SINCE: December 2015
JOINED WW TO: Ease joint and back pain and set a healthy example for her daughter
USED TO: Eat fast food, pizza, burgers, fries, tacos, and huge bowls of ice cream before bed; move very little
NOW SHE: Eats lean proteins, fruits, and veggies; plans ahead and packs snacks; cooks lighter versions of the recipes she loves; enjoys just one portion of ice cream; and walks on the regular
JOINED WW TO: Stop her weight from holding her back
USED TO: Binge eat fast food, overeat large quantities in response to stress and boredom
NOW SHE: Jogs, strength trains, or hops on the elliptical almost every day, eats healthy snacks like popcorn, and still enjoys her favorite foods like chicken nuggets, pizza, and spaghetti
Neil Lost 24 Pounds (And is Married to the WW CEO!)
“The best thing about the WW app, I quickly realized, is that it forces you to focus on what you’re eating. Just paying attention helps you figure out what to eat in the first place, and that makes everything easier. Most importantly, from day one, I never felt like I was on a diet because I could eat what I wanted.”
Neil is married to Weight Watchers CEO, Mindy Grossman. I bet he got a good discount at sign-up!
Nadalie Before & After + Weight Loss WW Results
“WW helped me better understand serving sizes. The SmartPoints system nudged me toward filling up on more nutritious fruits, veggies, and lean protein. One of my favorite snacks these days is a banana and PBfit! “I began to walk almost every day, eventually adding jogging, spinning, and strength training to the mix. It feels great to figure out what works for me!” – Nadalie lost 67lbs!*
No coupons found.
Before & After: Jennifer Hudson
Jennifer Hudson lost 80 pounds after having her son in 2009. In an interview with People magazine, she said, “My experience with Weight Watchers has been truly life-changing. I am grateful for what I have learned throughout the process and will always take it with me.”
WW Before & After: Kate
WW MEMBER SINCE: 2019
JOINED WW TO: Lose weight without overhauling her lifestyle
USED TO: Eat entire personal pizzas and chips by the bag without feeling satiated
NOW SHE: Exercises portion control and plans ahead for indulgences so she can have her pizza and lose weight, too
WW WEIGHT LOSS results: 44lbs ?
WW Results: Megan Lost 75 Lbs.
WW (Weight Watchers) MEMBER SINCE: November 2018
JOINED WW TO: Take back control of my life and learn lifelong habits after many attempts at crash dieting
USED TO: Eat fast food 5 or 6 times a week, snack out of boredom, and eat until she felt sick
NOW SHE: Keeps her kitchen stocked with healthy options, makes healthier versions of the dishes she loves, takes Orange Theory classes, and is training for a half marathon after running her first 5K this year
WW WEIGHT LOSS RESULTS: 75.4lbs
WW: Kayleigh’s 100+ Pound Weight Loss:
WW (Weight Watchers) MEMBER SINCE: June 2018
JOINED WW TO: Overcome her insecurities and find happiness
USED TO: Eat lots of fast food and avoid physical activity
NOW SHE: Cooks most meals at home using ZeroPoint foods—including lots of veggies—and earns FitPoints on the elliptical and Stairmaster
WW WEIGHT LOSS: 107lbs
Photos of WW Weight Loss Results: Jennifer
MEMBER SINCE: October 2018
JOINED WW TO: Get fit for her wedding and beyond
USED TO: Eat heavy restaurant meals with fried starters like cheese fries and order in ice cream sundaes and shakes for dessert
NOW SHE: Cooks foods she loves—like burgers—at home using SmartPoints-friendly swaps (like turkey instead of beef); exercises portion control; and runs, cycles, and lifts weights
WW WEIGHT LOSS results: 64.4 pounds
Natalie Lost 100+ Pounds w/ Weight Watchers:
WW MEMBER SINCE: April 2018
JOINED WW TO: Get healthier—and stay that way!
USED TO: Eat out regularly, binge-eat in private, and attempt extreme diets like Paleo, low-carb, and keto without success
NOW SHE: Makes lighter versions of her favorite dishes like pizza, sundaes, and cookies, leans on WW’s Connect community to find new recipes, and began walking, running, and racing as well as weight-training
WW WEIGHT LOSS: 106.4lbs
WW: Shelly Before & After Photos:
WW (Weight Watchers) MEMBER SINCE: May 2016
JOINED WW TO: Get off her high blood pressure and type 2 diabetes meds
USED TO: Eat mostly fast food and sweets
NOW SHE: Cooks with fresh ingredients, walks often, and interval trains with dumbbells
WEIGHT LOSS: 38.4lbs ?
Before & After Photos: Melody
WW Weight Watchers MEMBER SINCE: January 2018
JOINED WW TO: Lower her high blood pressure, tie her shoes without discomfort, and keep up with her two young sons
USED TO: Eat a pint of ice cream every night and pay little attention to portions
NOW SHE: Eat more whole foods; measures, weighs, and tracks foods with SmartPoints; takes after-dinner walks; and practices yoga, strength training, and dancing
WEIGHT LOSS: 61.6lbs ?
*Related: Thinking of getting invisible teeth aligners? Check out our Byte Before and After Photos
Before & After WW: Jessica Simpson
Jessica Simpson lost 50+ pounds of baby weight with Weight Watchers in 2014 before becoming a WW brand ambassador.
First Weight Watchers Before & After: Founder Jean Nidetch!
Weight Watchers founder Jean Nidetch is featured in the first Weight Watchers transformation photo. She dropped 70 pounds to reach her goal weight of 142 on Oct. 30, 1962 and then founded Weight Watchers International shortly after in 1963.
More WW (Weight Watchers) Before & After Photos:
Want to see more photos? Here are a bunch more before and afters! Just click any picture to see it larger:
Erin lost 76 poundsBefore & After: Ginger, 65 lbsElise lost 24 poundsChristine lost 68 poundsBefore & After: ChelseaKarla lost 57 poundsBefore & After: JessKaitlin lost 63 lbs.Before & After, Grace lost 93 lbsElizabeth lost 63 lbs.Antoine lost 64 poundsBrittany lost 28 lbs.Meredith lost 78 lbs.Ashley lost 28 poundsBefore& After Tricia lost 16 lbs.Rosemary lost 156 poundsSteph lost 100+ poundsBefore & After: Amanda, 58 lbs.Before & After: Lacy lost 60 lbsDeja lost 38 pounds
Weight Watchers Before & After Photos on Instagram!
Want to see more weight loss results and transformation pictures from WW users? The WW Instagram page is updated regularly with inspiring posts and photos, including before and afters. Here are a few highlights:
Why Weight Watchers Doesn’t Post Before & After Photos:
Why doesn’t Weight Watchers post before and after photos? WW no longer posts transformation pictures online anymore, as they don’t want to imply that weight loss has a start and finish.
In fact, WW CEO, Mindy Grossman, recently said, “We’ve made the decision to lose the expression ‘before and after’ because our members’ journeys are so much more about then than now,” she said. “A journey of health, with no beginning, middle or end.” – source
OK, well we think it’s great to show photos of inspiring WW weight loss transformations, so we’ll keep posting them here!
Weight Watchers Before and After Photos of Transformations Are Inspiring!
WW (Weight Watchers) has helped millions of women and men lose weight and achieve their weight loss goals for a healthier and happier life.
Is Weight Watchers the best program for you? Maybe. No single diet or wellness program is best for every person, as people have unique personalities, lifestyles, and weight loss goals. Also, be sure to talk to your doctor before making any drastic changes to your diet or attempting to lose a lot of weight!
If you do consider joining WW, check out the featured sign-up promotion below, or all WW coupons here. (WW Canada)
Not 100% sold on WW? Consider the super-hot weight loss app, Noom, which has been called “Weight Watchers for Millenials. (WW vs Noom?) Both Noom and Club Jenny have a free trial this month.
Want to see more WW before and after photos? You can visit their Instagram page, or read about featured success stories on WeightWatchers.com
*People following the WW program can expect to lose 1-2 lbs per week.